The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA

Editorials

January 12, 2014

Contentious council | Empty seat may be vacant for some time

JOHNSTOWN — The calendar has changed.

    So have some of the names and faces.

Unfortunately, it’s beginning to look like 2014 could bring more of the same for Johnstown City Council.

When Frank Janakovic was sworn in as mayor, it created an opening on council, as he was forced to resign his councilman position in order to assume his new post. But the selection of a seventh member could be every bit as tricky as it was the last time the board faced a similar situation. That was last year, when the death of Ann Wilson resulted in an opening. A dozen people applied for the post, but the sitting members – most of whom still sit on council – could not agree on a replacement. Pete Vizza, William Gentile Jr. and former Mayor Tom Trigona voted twice for Fred Mickel. Marie Mock, Janakovic and former Councilwoman Rose Howarth supported Anthony “Red” Pinizzotto in the first vote, then backed Angela Gorzelsky in the second vote in what they hoped at the time would be a compromise selection.

The strategy didn’t work, as Vizza, Gentile and Trigona held their ground.

After the 45-day deadline to fill the post passed, a three-member panel of Cambria County judges, consisting of David Tulo-witzki, Patrick Kiniry and Linda Rovder Fleming, was assigned the task of appointing a member. Ultimately, the judges decided on Joseph Taranto – one of the original applicants – to fill the void.

So, here we sit, nearly a year later, in a similar situation. At least one of the council members is confident that history will not repeat itself.

“I’m optimistic,” Vizza told our Dave Sutor. “There were a lot of people in that field last time that were good.”

Excuse us if we don’t share his optimism. We’re hopeful that plenty of good people will again apply for the position; we’re just not so sure that council members will agree on what constitutes an acceptable candidate. The more pessimistic among us might say the most important characteristic is which faction the candidate sides with – the Vizza/Gentile/David Vitovich group or the Janakovic/Mock/Nunzio Johncola block – on key votes. That’s the way it broke down when the members voted for a replacement to the deputy mayor seat that Janakovic previously held. Vizza, Gentile and Vitovich voted for Vizza while Janakovic, Mock and Johncola voted for Mock.

We’re afraid that council will continue to be split along those lines and be unable to agree on a seventh – and likely tie-breaking – member. The best-case scenario, of course, would be for an independent-minded, clear-thinking individual who would help bring the two factions together.

Mock shared similar sentiments with Sutor.

“I’m hoping we can (get past the division),” she said. “I think, at this point, we’ve just got to move ahead. This kind of stuff is nonsense. We’re not going to get anywhere by doing this. We’ve got to move ahead. I want somebody on council that is a free thinker, a clear thinker with common sense and not influenced by anybody.”

We’d love for that to be the case. But, if history is any kind of guide, we’re not betting on that happening any time soon.

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
Editorials
Poll

What is the biggest key to reducing gun violence in Johnstown?

Tackling the area's drug problem.
Controlling folks moving into city housing.
Monitoring folks in treatment centers and halfway houses.
Tougher sentencing by the court system.
More police on the streets.

     View Results
Order Photos


Photo Slideshow

House Ads