Should you spank your child?
That’s not for us to answer, but we do encourage parents in our region to read the results of a national study on spanking as a means of disciplining children.
The comprehensive study was released last week by the American Academy of Pediatrics and is published in the May issue of the academy’s journal, Pediatrics.
We learned of the study in an article in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette by Pohla Smith.
AAP’s latest research concurred with earlier studies that spanking can make young children aggressive years later. In one segment of the research, the study found that spanking a child of 3 more than twice a month was associated with an increased risk for higher levels of aggression at age 5.
“You can’t argue with (parents who believe in spanking)” Lawrence Newman, a psychologist at Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC, told Smith. “The parents say, ‘But it works!’ ”
Their proof, he says, is that it stops kids from misbehaving.
Perhaps, but ... here’s what we also know:
Newspaper stories about child abuse tear at our heartstrings just as much as they do to most of our readers. And often, we read that the abuse was the result of a parent’s discipline gone too far, and that includes spanking that developed into something much more.
We’ve never had a child psychologist or pediatrician on our editorial boards, so we’ve naturally shied away from a stand on the issue of spanking at home or paddling (corporal punishment) in schools, which has been banned in Pennsylvania’s public classrooms since 2005 – although “reasonable force” in still permitted under certain circumstances, according to the state Department of Education.
For a young child, experts today are more likely to suggest that parents use nonviolent punishments such as time-outs.
Those means obviously don’t work as well for teenagers, but neither does physically abusing an individual.
It’s parents’ responsibility to discipline their children appropriately when the need arises, and not pass the job onto others.
Should you spank your child?
Readers' Forum 4-16 | Don't get caught in the spin
This is a response to the abundance of “spin” used by Katie Dorian on April 13 (“ ‘Spin’ column will cause vertigo”) and Debra Taczanowsky (“Everyone must stand up against ‘spin,’ ” April 8) condemning such spin.
Enjoy the fun of fishing | Three million trout available to anglers
A popular saying seen on T-shirts and bumper stickers reads, “A bad day of fishing is better than a good day of work.”
Fitting tribute to Marine | Documentary of Michael Strank in works
It is a small, volcanic island in the Pacific Ocean, 750 miles south of Tokyo. Normally, an island that is only 8 square miles – 4 miles wide by 2 miles long – would not receive much attention.
Readers' Forum 4-15 | Can we survive constantly changing weather?
Does it matter if we believe in global warming? It is what it is, and we will die anyhow.
Readers' Forum 4-14 | A wonderful day for the kids
I would like to say job well-done to the students and staff of the Greater Johnstown School District for managing a wonderful event called Kiwanis/Key Club Pancake Day that took place on April 5 at Greater Johnstown High School.
Above the law? | City, manager ignore open records stipulations
Rules were made to be broken, according to an old adage.
And it seems to us, and several Johnstown residents, that that adage is what City Manager Kristen Denne adheres to.
Readers' Forum 4-13 | 'Spin' column will cause vertigo
I decided to take the advice Debra Taczanowsky offered in her column, “Everyone must stand up against ‘spin’.” I had a hard time standing up, though, after her spin knocked me flat on the floor.
Readers' Forum 4-12 | Cast, crew put on uplifting entertainment
Kudos to the Conemaugh Township Area High School Music Department on its outstanding production recently of “Fiddler on the Roof.”
Laurels and barbs
Laurel: YouthBuild Johnstown participants got to tout their accomplishments to community and business leaders during National YouthBuild Day.
Don't let 'Hawks down | Help team extend playoff season
The Johnstown Tomahawks could be nearing the end of their second season in the North American Hockey League.
- More Editorials Headlines
- Readers' Forum 4-16 | Don't get caught in the spin