The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA

May 2, 2013

Readers' Forum 5-2 | Swiss gov’t comparison grossly misleading

Submitted by Readers

— Joseph Torchia’s Readers’ Forum letter on April 26, “Be prepared by arming every household,” said that “The Swiss government provides weapons, unlike our government, which wants to take ours away.”

That is grossly misleading.

Not only isn’t our government trying to take guns away (if so, when and where was it attempted?), but the Swiss weapons he refers to are military property issued to conscripts in the equivalent of the Swiss army reserve. Switzerland has no standing army. Instead, it has mandatory military training for young, able-bodied males and relies on them for its defense. That isn’t a “unique” concept. We had no standing army and relied on a “well regulated militia” back in 1791 when the Second Amendment was ratified.

The percentage of households with guns in Switzerland is significantly lower (10 percent) than in the U.S. (18 percent).

As to our supposed “pushing Christian teaching aside for secularism” and “centuries of Christian influence having shaped the souls of the Swiss,” 20 percent of Swiss citizens practice no religion. Depending on the source, that’s 25 percent to 100 percent more than the percentage of U.S. citizens who practice no religion.

Torchia also rails that “Radical Muslims want to destroy our country.” He may be surprised to know that 4.5 percent of Swiss citizens are Muslims, three times the percentage of Americans who practice Islam.

Finally, before the “Patriots” start firing back at me, I own guns, including former military issue assault rifles. I just don’t like facts being cherry-picked and twisted to appear to support arguments they in truth do not support at all.

Daniel Waltimire


Alternative to Newtown weapons a sure bet

Here is my answer to Frank Filia’s April 26 question, “What would have happened in Newtown, Conn., if the shooter would not have had access to firearms in his home?”

I’m pretty sure Adam Lanza would have stolen a gun somewhere. No, that would be illegal. I’m sure he wouldn’t do that.

OK, he would have probably made a backpack full of Molotov cocktails with gasoline and burned the school. No, that, too, would be illegal.

All right then, he would have waited until a group of little kids were huddling at a bus stop and run over them with his mother’s car. Sorry, that one is illegal, too.

Pipe bombs, illegal. Knife attack on a group of little kids, illegal. Everything I have mentioned is illegal, as is murder in the first place. Do you really think that this psycho would have just given up and went to play video games instead?

Doug Crouse


Religious scandals have no borders

For the past seven years, I have noticed the headline stories in the newspaper about Catholic priest scandals. I don’t mind you doing this, if you would give equal time to the other religions.

I hear Protestant ministers are even worse, but, somehow, society today thinks the Catholic church is rich with evil.

Think about it and you should know that Satan’s No. 1 targets are our religious leaders of all faiths.

Jimmy Bakker was once a great evangelist, but he fell from grace. I believe Osama bin Laden was once a Muslim leader also.

If the devil can destroy our religious leaders, he is happy. A better thing for all of us to do is to pray for all of our wonderful spiritual leaders, because basically our beliefs are so similar.

Donna Soisson


Readers have a thirst for more about LaRod

On April 27, I was most happy to read and see featured our own LaRod Stephens-Howling, and it happened on his birthday. How very great he must feel.

Surely, he must have enjoyed a great family upbringing. Please, on a future date, feature his family and so much more as he progresses. We The Tribune-Democrat subscribers would appreciate reading about his accomplishments – his minor education, brothers and family; where did his parents come from?

As a Steelers fan, we’d all like to know.

His parents must be very proud of him.

Nancy Arnone


An editorial on this topic appears today.

Click here to subscribe to The Tribune-Democrat print edition.

Click here to subscribe to The Tribune-Democrat e-edition.