The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA

Latest News

December 5, 2012

Murderer seeks new trial

— Linda Fleming, now a Cambria County judge who normally presides at hearings, testified as a witnesss Wednesday in Federal District Court in Johnstown about helping to defend Kevin Siehl in his murder trial 20 years ago in county court.

Fleming was an assistant public defender who worked with David Weaver, then Cambria’s chief public defender, in representing Siehl, who was convicted in May 1992 of first-degree murder in the stabbing death of his 29-year-old estranged wife, Christine.

Her body was found July 14, 1991, in the bathtub at her apartment in the city’s Moxham section. She had been stabbed more than 20 times.

Siehl, 56, now serving a life sentence at the State Correctional Institution-Huntingdon, did not testify at his trial, but has maintained his innocence and presented alibi evidence by his father, a brother and a neighbor that he was elsewhere the night of the slaying. One of the prosecution’s most damaging pieces of evidence was a thumbprint – identified as Siehl’s – found on the showerhead in the bathroom.

He has waged a legal battle for years seeking to overturn his conviction and get a new trial, but was rebuffed until the U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals sent the case back to the district court for an evidentiary hearing on the effectiveness of Weaver and Fleming in their representation.

That hearing, ordered in 2009, finally got under way Wednesday before U.S. District Magistrate Judge Keith Pesto.

The focus was on the defense expert, W. Stewart Bennett, a New York forensics expert whose expertise now has come into question, particularly on fingerprint and blood evidence.

Fleming recalled that Bennett had been recommended by another public defender who had used Bennett in an unrelated murder trial. Bennett had testified in other counties in Pennsylvania and other states as a forensics expert, she said.

“There were no red flags that Mr. Bennett was anything but qualified,” Fleming said.

The defense legal team wanted to use Bennett as an expert at trial, including his opinion that nobody could say with certainty when the thumbprint had been left on the showerhead, she said. The defense believed that would challenge the prosecution’s evidence because Siehl had told police that he had not made a habit of showering at her apartment, Fleming testified.

But then on March 23, 1991 – just a couple of months before trial, “he dropped a bomb on us – incriminating evidence of (Siehl having been) at the crime scene,” Fleming recalled.

Bennett said that he found on the soles of Siehl’s sneakers traces of blood and cat litter and pieces of broken mirror, “all suggesting that the sneakers were at the crime scene at or near the time of the murder,” she said.

Fleming said that she and Weaver were unable to find a way to limit Bennett’s testimony during the trial to prevent the damaging evidence from coming out during the prosecution’s questioning if he took the stand.

Asked why the defense attorneys had not questioned Bennett’s findings – which came after the sneakers had been examined at the state police crime lab – Fleming said, “We believed that our expert found something that the state police had missed.”

She testified that she was surprised when told by federal Public Defender Lisa Freeland that the prosecution had the sneakers retested during trial, with the lab reporting back only, “No formal report required.” That information had not been supplied by prosecutors,” Fleming said.

She also said that she and Weaver did not seek to have a second expert appointed who could be used at trial because the defense’s legal resources had been capped at $6,000 by Judge Gerard Long. She said that she doubted whether Long would have approved additional expenses.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Latest News
  • smothers ‘It breaks my heart’: Shooting victim’s death leaves trail of shattered lives

    Victoria Smothers knows what people thought when they heard that a young black male had been shot to death in Moxham last week.

    April 16, 2014 2 Photos

  • School violence studied

    On a typical day last year, Pennsylvania schools caught 11 students toting weapons similar to ones used to slash 21 students and a security guard at a Pittsburgh-area high school, according to the state Department of Education. An untold number of others likely brought weapons to school but weren’t caught, safety experts say.

    April 16, 2014

  • egg hunt17 ACRP quietly notes 25th anniversary

    There will be little or no fanfare accompanying Alternative Community Resource Program’s 25th anniversary.
    And that’s how the executive director, Frank Janakovic, wants it.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • windber17 Windber students earn top ‘Overchiever’ rank

    Windber Area school’s PSSA scores have been tops in the region for the past several years.
    This year, they’re among the head of the class statewide, Pittsburgh Business Times annual Schools Guide shows.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Wise, Charles Police charge bank robbery suspect

    A Johnstown man was jailed on $250,000 bond after police said he robbed the West End Branch of AmeriServ Financial. Charles Wise, 48, of Barron Avenue, was charged with two counts of robbery.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Inmate awaits sentencing for assault on guard

    A former inmate faces up to 15 years in prison when he is sentenced for assaulting a corrections officer at State Correctional Institution-Somerset, authorities said.

    April 16, 2014

  • windber pool Pool stays afloat despite troubles

    When a valve broke at the Windber Recreation Park pool last month, its municipal authority caretakers feared that meant the end for the pool’s aged, much-patched liner.
    But the old liner has held up – a stroke of luck that will save Windber Municipal Authority from having to seek a line of credit to cover repairs or risk delaying the pool opening, the authority’s recreation director, C.W. Beckley, said.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Creativity blossoming for spring art show

    The 16th annual Art in Bloom spring art show will brighten the Cambria County Courthouse in Ebensburg from noon to 6 p.m. April 26 and 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. April 27.

    April 16, 2014

  • Alcatraz Challenge offers escape from routine

    Greater Johnstown Community YMCA is gearing up for its indoor biathlon, the Alcatraz Challenge.

    April 16, 2014

  • Local briefs 4/17/2014

    April 16, 2014


Do you think that Jack Williams will get the 270 signatures from city residents needed in order to have a referendum placed on a municipal ballot to have the city's pressure test mandate repealed?

I'm not sure
     View Results
Order Photos

Photo Slideshow

House Ads