subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sat, Aug 30 2008 

Published: February 12, 2008 11:02 pm    print this story   email this story   comment on this story  

FreightCar case headed to higher court

By SHAWN PIATEK
The Tribune-Democrat

A battle over the future of former FreightCar America Inc. employees now is headed to a higher court.

And even in the wake of Monday’s ruling by a federal judge in Johnstown, it remains unclear whether those workers will return to their jobs while pursuing a lawsuit against the rail-car maker.

At issue now: Whether the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals will grant FreightCar’s request for a “stay” – which would allow the company to postpone implementation of a judge’s order to put those employees back to work at the now–shuttered Franklin Borough plant.

“Our clients are still without work, many of them without pay or health benefits,” said Pittsburgh attorney John Stember, whose firm is representing the workers.

“It is important that this proceeds expeditiously,” he added. “If the Third Circuit sees fit to deny the stay, our clients will return to work.”

Employees, with backing from the United Steelworkers union, filed a federal suit against FreightCar last year. They claim the company furloughed workers to prevent them from becoming eligible for retirement benefits.

In response to the workers’ request, U.S. District Judge Kim Gibson last month issued a preliminary injunction requiring FreightCar to put more than 180 union employees back on the job pending the lawsuit’s resolution.

The company appealed the injunction and also asked Gibson to delay enforcing his order while that appeal was heard.

Gibson on Monday issued a 99-page opinion explaining why he denied FreightCar’s request. The judge touched on several key points.

One of FreightCar’s main complaints was that the injunction will cause the company to suffer irreparable financial harm.

But Gibson noted that the local union employees stood to face the same irreparable harm. He said the two factors balanced one another, excluding them from having any bearing on his decision.

Gibson also wrote that he denied the stay because granting it would not render the company’s appeal of the injunction moot.

He also ruled against the stay because, he said, granting one would not be in the best interest of the public, noting the harm done to Franklin Borough’s fiscal health due to lost tax revenue as a result of the company shifting work to other plants.

“It’s a very thorough decision, and obviously Judge Gibson took a lot of time and care with it,” Stember said.

Gibson said he is deferring his ruling on a civil contempt of court motion filed against FreightCar for not immediately following the preliminary injunction’s orders.

Gibson said he will not act on the contempt motion until the Third Circuit makes its own decision on FreightCar’s request for a stay.

Stember said he couldn’t be certain when the Third Circuit will rule on the stay motion. He said he expects his firm will file a response next week to the company’s motion.

If the Third Circuit also rules against the stay, Stember said there is a chance the furloughed workers could be entitled to back wages from Jan. 11 forward.

“It will be up to court to make that decision,” Stember said. “But our position is the back pay goes back to at least the day of the injunction.”

FreightCar America officials did not respond to a request for comment.

print this story   email this story   comment on this story  

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.



monster
wheels
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premium Jobs

Servers Wanted
SERVERS WANTED, must be avail. all shifts, incl. evenings & weekends, no exp. necessary, will train. No phone ca...>MORE

Meadow view LPN's

MEADOW VIEW
NURSING CENTER

Come join our dedicated, professional staff. We’re recruit
...>MORE

RN

MEADOW VIEW
NURSING CENTER

RN-
Assistant Director
Of Nursing

Join our progres
...>MORE

Customer Service Reps
DON’T WAIT!
CALL US TODAY FOR A
GREAT OPPORTUNITY!

We have immediate openings for
Customer Ser
...>MORE

CUSTOMER SERVICE REPS
CUSTOMER
SERVICE REPS
CallcenterHR, Inc. is growing. We are looking for motivated individuals to become Cus
...>MORE


CDL Class A Driver Wanted
Local company seeking driver to haul oversize/overweight loads. Excellent pay and outstan
...>MORE

INTERMEDIA MARKETING POSITIONS
LOOKING TO EARN SOME EXTRA $$$?
Call InterMedi@ Marketing
Solutions. 1-800-520-4100
...>MORE

Youth Leader

YOUTH LEADER

Make a difference! FT & PT overnight positions 1-4 wknds./mon. (Fri. 5PM- Sun. 12:30PM)
...>MORE

ASSISTANT MIDDLE SCHOOL PRINCIPAL
ASSISTANT MIDDLE SCHOOL PRINCIPAL
The Marion Center Area School District is accepting applications for an Assistant
...>MORE

Certified Nurses Aides
CERTIFIED
NURSES AIDES

Are you looking for a great place to work?

Laurel View Village may jus
...>MORE

See all ads

Garage/Yard Sales


1227 SOAP HOLLOW RD. Fri., 8-7; Sat. 8-3. Longaberger, Art, Craft, Scrapbook Supplies, Collectibles, Furniture, Baseball...>MORE


RICHLAND YARD SALE 8am-2pm, Saturday - Aug. 30th. 311 Kerr Drive. Kids clothes, toys, HH & more. Quality sale! Rain Date...>MORE


8:00 AM to 3:00 PM, Friday the 29th and Saturday the 30th. 107 Maxwell Ave. Follow signs at the top of Ohio St., off of ...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Homes

TOWNHOUSE, RICHLAND
Townhouse- Richland Move-in cond.! 2 BR, 1.5 BA, family rm. Many updates. Brick & vinyl ext., beautiful wooded back yr...>MORE

Build your dream home, 12 acres
Build your dream home, 12 acres. trees (Soft Maple, Red Oak & Cherry). $80k as is. Jackson Twnsp., Central Cambria Schl....>MORE

Walnut Grove

WALNUT GROVE

2 houses for sale,
3 BR rented $350/mo,
& a 2 BR vacant,
$37,500 for both.<
...>MORE


ASH ST. PROPERTY FOR Rent/Rent with option to buy. New kitchen, carpeting, 2 bedrooms, Section 8 approved. 814-392-1182...>MORE


CENTRAL CAMBRIA SCHOOLS - Exquisitely remodeled, great starter or retirement home. 1 level living, 3 bedrooms, partially...>MORE

RICHLAND TWP. & SALON
RICHLAND TOWNSHIP

SUCCESSFUL BEAUTY SALON in Richland Twp. for sale. 1st flr. of 3 BR cape cod house, also at
...>MORE

See all ads

Don't Miss This!


STEELERS TICKETS 9/7 opener (Myron Cope), $250/pair. End zone. Call Jim 814-243-3626....>MORE


KITCHEN CHAIRS
(4) very nice chairs. Heavy duty white steel with decorative scrollwork, swivel, cushion seats. Hard
...>MORE


LIBERTY TAX SERVICE
FREE TAX SCHOOL
Earn extra income after taking course.
Flexible Schedules.
Con
...>MORE

See all ads


click here click here click here click here click here click here click here click here click here click here click here click here click here click here click here click here

 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index