The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA

Local Columnists

March 1, 2014

JIM SIEHL | Basketball officials never win

— Today’s column bounces from local politics to basketball after two previous articles concentrated on Jesse Topper’s successful launch into a new career as a state representative.

More specifically, the column deals with basketball officiating, beginning with a contentious call in the last 10 seconds that led to an assured loss for unbeaten Syracuse and exit from the top of the NCAA rankings.

An official disallowed a field goal, ruling charging as a Syracuse player drove the baseline and made contact with a Duke defender before banking in what would have been the tying field goal.

Jim Boeheim, a hall-of-fame coach in the waiting, exploded uncharacteristically off the bench. Tugging at his sports coat, he stormed onto the court in protest.

The Syracuse mentor of almost 40 years later said he had gone too far.

Officials promptly tagged him with two technical fouls and automatic banishment. Boeheim was later to say the ejection was only his second, with the first occurring in an exhibition game.

Rather than express regret for his actions, his concern was that a bad call had decided the game.

Any chance Syracuse had to win ended when Duke converted three of the four technical fouls, leaving TV pundits putting the blame on Boeheim rather than the controversial call.

Was it a bad call?

Yes it was – after viewing repeat televised playbacks. But one easily missed! In the split-time the action developed, if the official failed to see the defender slide into the path of the driver already leaving his feet (as was the case), then the call should have been blocking on the defender.

Officials can’t win on these charge-block situations.

Highly emotional partisan fans of course see it only their way.

From my experience as a PIAA basketball official for 20 years working with partners that included the late Hugh Crocker and Homer Rice as well as Dick Lucas and Gene Podratsky, making the charge call was almost sure to draw heavy jeers.

It really is not that hard to get the call right. Once a defender has established a position in front of the dribbler and contact ensues, if the defender has moved sideways or backwards the call is against the dribbler. If the defender advances any part of the angle, the call is blocking.

Once a dribbler is committed to the basket, a defender may not leap/move into his or her path to establish position, which is what the Duke defender did. Thus, the bad call.

Of all sports, basketball has to be the most difficult to officiate, with its speed and frequent physical contact. I always believed the difference between good and poor officiating is the ability to judge incidental contact.

No one wants to see a foul-shooting contest and unnecessary interruption of play.

One of my pet peeves are foul calls made against defenders clearly making good blocks on attempted field goals.

The hand is part of the ball. Any foul has to occur from the wrist down. Otherwise, the contact is legal and play should continue.

If there is one rule all fans know, it is the three-second rule. It is a violation to spend more than three seconds camped inside the paint.

As a result, watchful spectators are quick to gain the attention of the referees screaming:

“Three seconds!! Three seconds!!”

Good officiating ignores the violation if the player is in the process of leaving.

Looking back on the golden years of amateur sports in Johnstown, the basketball opportunity was huge. During a period from the ’40s through the following three decades, the city sponsored senior and junior basketball leagues and three highly-competitive Sunday school leagues flourished.

Catholic parochial schools were developing outstanding talent for the high school basketball program. The city’s population was more than 60,000 then with the steel mills and the coal mining industries booming. When those jobs disappeared, the exodus began, and with it a gradual decline in amateur sports. The city’s population now is in the 20,000 range.

Closing with a Bedford County flavor, Royce Waltman enjoyed a highly successful career as a basketball coach at Bedford High School, later as an assistant to the legendary Bobby Knight at Indiana University and then as head coach at Indiana State.

Royce left me with an indelible memory of a competitive fire that was part of his quiet disposition. After a District 5 playoff loss to Conemaugh Township, Royce came into the dressing room and addressed Gene Podratsky and myself. He complimented us for working a good game and then he said:

“This is what this game meant to me.” With that, he turned and punched his fist into the cement block wall, turned and left the room.

Emotions represent a big part of sports.

I guess the Orange fans should not be too hard on Coach Boeheim.

Jim Siehl of Schellsburg, formerly of Richland Township, retired in 1991 after 44 years as a reporter for The Tribune-Democrat.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Local Columnists
  • Local Columnists

    Robin L. Quillon
    Chip Minemyer
    Tom Lavis
    Mike Mastovich
    Cory Isenberg
    Zachary Hubbard
    Michele Bender
    Bill Eggert


    July 6, 2010

  • Michele Bender MICHELE M. BENDER | Time to can clutter

    I’m “downsizing.” Sixteen years ago, this house was perfect for me. I gave parties. Friends came and stayed for weekends. Great insulation protected visitors from highway noise.
    Yep, I had the time of my life.
    But I’m 16 years older, and my friends are, too.  They no longer travel like they did. Parties wear us out by 10 p.m.

    June 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • Siehl, Jim color JIM SIEHL | Richland student excels in class, on field

    Ben Verhovsek is a humble, soft-spoken young man who by his nature resists all forms of public adulation.

    June 14, 2014 2 Photos

  • Music, comedy on tap for pre-Thunder bash

    With Thunder in the Valley right around the corner, organizers are hoping to make this year’s event the best yet and are holding a launch party to get people in the mood for the motorcycle rally.

    May 10, 2014

  • Jim Siehl JIM SIEHL | Music to my ears

    Seldom has $15 produced such a high level of entertainment as it did a few weeks ago when I found myself in the second row just left of center keeping back the tears once again during my third live performance of “Les Miserables.”

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • Curtis, Shawn SHAWN CURTIS | Pirates win has familiar feel

    As much as all the fuzzy feelings of the 2013 season came to an end when Pirates pitcher Francisco Liriano fired a first-pitch strike to Emilio Bonifacio at 1:14 p.m. on Monday afternoon at PNC Park, the 1-0 win took the shape that many Pittsburgh wins did a season ago.

    March 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • Eric Knopsnyder ERIC KNOPSNYDER | A fresh take on funnies

    Did you notice some funny business in our comics pages recently?
    Many of you did and contacted the newsroom to ask why “Doonesbury” and “For Better or For Worse” were no longer appearing in our publication.
    There’s a simple explanation: They are no longer being produced.

    March 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Jim Siehl JIM SIEHL | Basketball officials never win

    Today’s column bounces from local politics to basketball after two previous articles concentrated on Jesse Topper’s successful launch into a new career as a state representative.

    March 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Michele Bender Michele Mikesic Bender | Playing the name game

    So, did you decide on the ‘popcorn dress’  for the church dinner?” asked Judi, my Communion Lady.
    “No, I think the ‘hydrangea dress’ might be better,’’ I answered.
    “You name your clothes?” Denise’s jaw dropped.

    February 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Bill Eggert Columnist Photo Bill Eggert | A heartfelt message of thanks

    February is the month the medical community sets aside for matters related to heart health. That makes sense, given that Valentine’s Day is right in the middle of the month. So it was ironic that I found myself dealing with the matter of the heart in a serious way this month.
    This column is a valentine to the staff of the Conemaugh Health System.

    February 22, 2014 1 Photo


Do you think pet obituaries should be included with death notices?

Yes, my pet is considered a member of the family.
No, pet obituaries are inappropriate.
Pet obituaries should be placed on a different page in the newspaper.
     View Results
Order Photos

Photo Slideshow

House Ads