The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA


December 17, 2012

In Mt. Holly Springs, a tree for tradition — and 'Peanuts'

Mount Holly Springs — Linus said it best in "A Charlie Brown Christmas" — "I never thought it was such a bad little tree ... Maybe it just needs a little love."

Like the cast of that classic cartoon, the people of Mt. Holly Springs have taken to heart the decoration of a scrawny little evergreen.

In the process, they have created an enduring holiday tradition on a patch of ground by the railroad tracks along a lonely stretch of Route 34.

Set on a raised bed of earth protected by wooden beams, the current tree is actually the fourth or fifth evergreen to be decorated in this fashion.

The original was cut down by unknown culprits at night on Christmas 1998. Brad Whitlock contacted The Sentinel the next day to report the incident.

I remember this story as one of my first assignments with the newspaper. In the headline, we dubbed the villain responsible "a Grinch."


As the story goes, the original tree was probably growing out of the rocky soil for years before it caught the eye of Whitlock on Christmas Eve 1996.

In a store, Whitlock saw a set of battery-powered lights he thought would look nice in the tree. Out of impulse, he and his wife Jennifer went out and decorated it with the lights.

Sometime that night, someone removed the lights, prompting Whitlock to call the police. At first, he thought the police took down the lights out of concern they posed a traffic hazard. That was not the case at all. The lights had been stolen.

For the next two years, someone kept decorating what locals call the "Charlie Brown Tree" every time a holiday rolled around. They would hang hearts on its branches on Valentine's Day, shamrocks on St. Patrick's Day and pumpkins for Halloween. The identity of this person was a mystery.

This continued until Christmas Day 1998 when the original tree was cut down, touching off outrage in the surrounding community. Someone put up a sign with words painted in orange: "To whoever cut down the tree: You are a lousy person."

Standing at the foot of the sign — as if in memorial — was a pot of soil wrapped in red foil with a tiny sprig of pine. It could have ended there very easily, but the people of Mt. Holly Springs would not have it. A new tree was planted in the same general area as the first.

Since then, the Charlie Brown Tree in its many incarnations has been run over by a vehicle, clubbed with a stick and cut down at least another time. Replacements were always planted in the same general area as the original tree.


Romaine Toner is the latest person tasked with trimming the community tree. She became caretaker about 12 years ago when the woman who used to decorate the tree wanted someone else to take over. They knew each other from the ladies auxiliary of VFW Post 7343.

"I just like to do it," Toner said. "I try to decorate it for most every holiday. If it's not decorated, I hear about it. People tell me how nice it is. They tell me never to quit."

Local residents also get into the act. Last Christmas season, someone donated the three wise men that are currently on display. A week later, someone from Gardners included a baby Jesus in a manger. More recently, someone put out a bowl with some cookies, perhaps for Santa Claus.

No matter the holiday, Toner includes yellow ribbons or patriotic colors as a salute to those who serve in the military. This was especially true after Army Master Sgt. Scott R. Ball, a local Guardsman, was killed in an ambush in the Kunar Province in Afghanistan on Aug. 27, 2007.

"He was a relation of mine," Toner said. Other times, she decorated the tree in memory of the Sept. 11 terror attacks and the seven astronauts who died in the space shuttle Columbia disaster of Feb. 1, 2003.

"Romaine is very dedicated," said Lois Stoner, a local hairdresser. "She always thinks about what she is going to put on the tree. She enjoys giving that to the town."

Stoner added that the Charlie Brown Tree has become something very sentimental to the people of Mt. Holly Springs. So much so, the local Holly Pharmacy even made gift cards with the tree on it.

In 2008, the borough planted the latest tree in the raised bed for better protection. Over the years, The Charlie Brown Tree has achieved some celebrity status with visitors from as far as Florida and Alaska stopping to have a look, Toner said.




Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • beach boys.jpg 'Love those Beach Boys

    Despite riding the wave of success for more than 50 years, founding member Mike Love of The Beach Boys is anything but bored.

    March 16, 2014 2 Photos

  • third day 1.JPG Christian entertainers ready to rock arena

    Top Christian performers will join together for one big evening of music.

    March 16, 2014 3 Photos

  • raz.jpg "Grown Ups 2" razzed

     "Grown Ups 2" is making the most noise at this year's Golden Raspberry Awards

    January 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • iStock_000022758530XSmall.jpg 12 annoying songs of Christmas

    It's that time of year, when Christmas songs fill shops, restaurants and your home. While anything on repeat can drive you mad, these 12 tunes are some of the most annoying.

    December 1, 2013 1 Photo

  • 8a5319c0595635132e67b282cdcd3136.jpg 6 creative ways to use your Thanksgiving leftovers

    The day of eating has passed and the fridge is full of leftovers. Check out our Pinterest board of recipes and creative ways to make meals from the remnants of Thanksgiving.

    November 29, 2013 1 Photo

  • 0801-couple-married.jpg Engagement ring lost, found on wedding-eve bike ride across Iowa

    When a bride-to-be lost her engagement ring while cycling across the state of Iowa last week, finding it again seemed like an impossible task.

    August 1, 2013 1 Photo

  • Film-Speedy Zombies_Denn.jpg Penn State prof lends zombie expertise to World War Z

    In a scene of the movie "World War Z," hundreds — maybe thousands — of virus-infected people swarm at the base of a wall in Jerusalem to find more humans to bite and infect. These zombies then form a human ladder to charge over the wall, which Israel's government had put up in the hope of sparing the city the wrath of the creatures.

    A professor at Penn State had something to do with that part of the movie.

    June 28, 2013 1 Photo

  • APTOPIX People Paula _Denn.jpg Paula Deen's 'Today' appearance ends in tears

    Paula Deen dissolved into tears during a "Today" show interview Wednesday about her admission that she used a racial slur in the past, saying anyone in the audience who's never said anything they've regretted should pick up a rock and throw it at her head.

    June 26, 2013 1 Photo

  • NY Premiere White Hou_Denn.jpg Movie Review | 'White House Down' doesn't live up to expectations

    "Independence Day", The Day After Tomorrow" and "2012" were guilty pleasures — excessive in every way, from their frenetic Wile E. Coyote action sequences down to their impressive A-list casts. And they worked. But while Emmerich's "White House Down" mostly sticks to the same formula, this latest cinematic assault on the Oval Office fails to deliver on the campaign promise that it will be as fun as the original "Die Hard."

    June 26, 2013 1 Photo

  • gtr-tatpastor01-06081_Denn.jpg For pastors, tattoos as symbols of faith

    As the spiritual leader for two United Church of Christ congregations, the Rev. Richard Lindsay-Bignell found a way to combine his love of the ministry and his passion for art.

    June 10, 2013 1 Photo


What is the biggest key to reducing gun violence in Johnstown?

Tackling the area's drug problem.
Controlling folks moving into city housing.
Monitoring folks in treatment centers and halfway houses.
Tougher sentencing by the court system.
More police on the streets.

     View Results