The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA

Sports

June 20, 2013

Judge rejects Steelers’ claim over new seating

PITTSBURGH — A judge on Thursday rejected a claim by the Pittsburgh Steelers that the taxpayer-funded city-county Sports and Exhibition Authority must pay most of the estimated

$30 million cost to add 3,000 seats to Heinz Field. 

Allegheny County Judge Joseph James’ ruling on Wednesday isn’t final. The issue could still be litigated at a trial in December, but the judge ruled the Steelers – for now – haven’t proved the plain language of the stadium lease supported the team. The team was hoping for a pretrial ruling on that particular issue.

The Steelers’ lawsuit contends the new seats at the 12-year-old stadium qualify as a “capital improvement” under which the authority must pay two-thirds of the cost. But authority officials argued the new seats qualify only as a “modification” of the stadium which, under the language of the lease, would mean the Steelers pay the entire bill.

James found the lease requires the Steelers to prove three things for the extra seats to qualify as a capital improvement: The Steelers must prove at least half of the NFL’s teams have made a similar addition with at least 25 percent of the cost borne by taxpayers; that the extra seats are “reasonably necessary” to keep the Steelers relatively competitive to other teams economically; and that the seats are needed to keep the stadium from becoming outdated compared with others built by NFL teams between 1999 and 2004.

Heinz Field, which opened in 2001, has 65,050 seats, ranking it 25th out of 31 NFL stadiums. The Steelers have a string of consecutive sellouts dating to 1972 and thousands of fans on a season-ticket waiting list, and could easily meet the demand for the new seats.

Steelers attorney Arthur Stroyd Jr. said he’ll try to prove that the judge’s interpretation of the lease is incorrect by taking depositions of sworn pretrial statements of officials involved in crafting the lease between now and the

Dec. 4 trial.

“We remain confident in our legal and factual position,” the team said in a statement. “Our lease clearly set out the obligations the SEA agreed to perform regarding our proposed improvements at Heinz Field.”

Authority Executive Director Mary Conturo said the judge’s ruling is a “clear affirmation” of the authority’s position.

“As we have maintained, the Steelers are not entitled to receive funding for a seating expansion simply by unilaterally notifying the SEA of their wishes. They are required to satisfy the terms of the lease,” she said.

The December trial will also determine whether the Steelers will be reimbursed for a new $5 million audio-visual control room at the stadium and have to pay for a new scoreboard proposed for the end zone opposite the proposed new seats.

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
Sports
  • Pirates cut down by Reds’ Cueto

    April 23, 2014

  • Penguins 0422 Blown leads are troubling trend in series

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Sunnehanna makes changes to tourney week

    April 22, 2014

  • Penguins 0421 Penguins finish hot to grab 2-1 series lead

    Brandon Sutter, Lee Stempniak and Jussi Jokinen scored in a span of 2:13 of the third period to revive the Penguins from yet another two-goal deficit in a 4-3 victory over the Columbus Blue Jackets on Monday night.

    April 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Pirates 0421 Pirates walk off against Reds to halt home skid

    Ike Davis became the first player to hit grand slams for different teams in the same April, and Neil Walker had a winning run single with two outs in the ninth inning as the Pittsburgh Pirates twice overcame deficits to beat the Reds 6-5 Monday night.
    Pittsburgh trailed 2-0 before Davis’ fourth-inning homer off Mike Leake.

    April 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Sitting Bulls bring home national sled hockey title

    The Johnstown Sitting Bulls disabled sled hockey team recently won a national championship.
    The team, comprised of disabled athletes from Cambria, Somerset, Indiana, Bedford and Blair counties, finished first in the Youth B Division at the USA Hockey National Disabled Hockey Festival held April 11-13 in Marlborough, Mass.

    April 21, 2014

  • Local Sports Briefs

    April 21, 2014

  • APTOPIX Boston Marathon.jpg Marathon men’s winner has names of victims on bib

    The winner of the Boston Marathon men’s race had the names of last year’s victims written in marker on the corners of his race bib.

    April 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Pirates Brawl 0420 Brewers top Pirates in game highlighted by dustup

    Ryan Braun homered in the ninth inning to tie it, then Khris Davis hit a home run in the 14th that put Milwaukee ahead for good.
    Yet those were hardly the big blows that attracted all the attention Sunday in the Brewers’ 3-2 victory over the Pittsburgh Pirates.

    April 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Football team ends boycott of embattled coach

    Minnesota State University-Mankato’s football team has ended its boycott of reinstated head coach Todd Hoffner, who successfully fought child pornography charges and other misconduct accusations that removed him from the job for 20 months.
    Hoffner said he assured the players, who refused to take the practice field Wednesday, that interim coach Aaron Keen, who led the team in Hoffner’s absence, will continue in a major role with the team.

    April 20, 2014

AP Sports Video
Poll

Should the NFL get rid of the extra-point attempt after a touchdown?

Yes
No
     View Results
Order Photos


Photo Slideshow