The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA


July 25, 2012

Shawn Curtis | It’s safe to forgive Meals

JOHNSTOWN — Through almost a generation of losing baseball, Pittsburgh Pirates fans had a lot of moments that served to discourage and infuriate even the most loyal and diehard fans. Yet through last season, there wasn’t that one moment since 1993 that served as a defining moment of demoralization.

Then as an innocent Tuesday night game at Turner Field in Atlanta became an early Wednesday morning marathon, that moment arrived in the form of Julio Lugo being tagged out by Mike McKenry in the 19th inning.

Home plate umpire Jerry Meals didn’t see it that way. Just minutes before the clock was set to strike 2 a.m. on July 27, Meals called Lugo safe to give the Braves a 4-3 win much to the chagrin of one loud and dedicated girl at Turner Field who yelled “Lets go Pirates!” long into the night and for those fans who stuck it out until the very end watching on television or listening on the radio.   

The call – while blamed by some for derailing the Pirates’ inspired play to that point in the season – did not cause the club’s eventual collapse toward a 19th straight losing season. It did accomplish two things, though:

n First, the bad call started a firestorm of tweets from Pirates fans that evolved into a worldwide trending topic on the social media site

While Pirates fans expressed anger at Meals through their smartphones or computers, Adam Caldwell – one of the creators of, found on Twitter @TPBAdam – opened the floodgates to a hashtag that trended around the world: #jerrymealssaysitssafe.

From there a group of fans who have had the worst luck in rooting for a winner, but developed a pretty good sense of humor about things in the meantime, were able to shine. Anger gave way to snarkiness for most of July 27, at least until the Pirates and Braves took the field that evening.

n Secondly, it temporarily united a fanbase that has a very defined division between those who have faith and almost infinite patience in what the organization is doing to build toward the future and those who believe that the team does not want to win due to its lack of spending on the major-league payroll.

At least for a day or two, the lightning rod for fan venom wasn’t ownership or management – in the front office or on the field – or even fellow rooters who just happen to be on the wrong side of the debate.  

Conversely there were reported threats on Meals, a Butler native, and his family for the miscue. The phone at the Meals’ residence in Perry Township, Ohio, had started ringing almost immediately after the game had ended. Hundreds of calls jammed the phone line in the early morning hours.

Meals wasn’t the first umpire to blow a call and he won’t be the last, yet in the days, weeks and months following the call his name is still associated with that balmy Atlanta morning. At least in the realm of umpires and referees, history remembers those who make the biggest mistakes. If an official becomes a trending topic, chances are that a call was missed.

But Mr. Meals may have accomplished something else when he signaled Lugo to be safe. His call might have been the nadir for Pirates fans who weren’t even alive to remember a team finishing above .500 and for those who recall better days for the club.

From the lowest of low points, there’s only one direction to go. While the Pirates plummeted to mediocrity in the weeks following the call to close 2011, the team has firmly entrenched itself into this year’s postseason discussion with just over two months remaining in the season.

Even if the Pirates (55-42) fail to reach the postseason, the another-year-older, another-year-wiser youngsters and a couple key offseason acquisitions should keep this team competitive and fun to watch until the very end of this season and for seasons to come.

While I’ve never blamed Meals for ruining the Pirates season in 2011, I’m thanking him for indirectly creating a turnaround point for the team’s fortunes and possibly lifting the black cloud that has hovered over the Pirates since Sid Bream’s famous slide in the same city with much more on the line in 1992.  

While it’s common for fans to hold onto grudges in sports, it’s time to let go of this one Pirates fans.

Jerry Meals, I forgive you.


 Shawn Curtis is a news assistant at The Tribune-Democrat. He can be followed on Twitter @shawncurtis430.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • Pirates Brawl 0420 Brewers top Pirates in game highlighted by dustup

    Ryan Braun homered in the ninth inning to tie it, then Khris Davis hit a home run in the 14th that put Milwaukee ahead for good.
    Yet those were hardly the big blows that attracted all the attention Sunday in the Brewers’ 3-2 victory over the Pittsburgh Pirates.

    April 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Football team ends boycott of embattled coach

    Minnesota State University-Mankato’s football team has ended its boycott of reinstated head coach Todd Hoffner, who successfully fought child pornography charges and other misconduct accusations that removed him from the job for 20 months.
    Hoffner said he assured the players, who refused to take the practice field Wednesday, that interim coach Aaron Keen, who led the team in Hoffner’s absence, will continue in a major role with the team.

    April 20, 2014

  • Penguins 0420a Game 3 pivotal for both teams

    Not so long ago, the Columbus Blue Jackets were the worst team in the NHL.
    Now they’re heading home for tonight’s Game 3 of their first-round Stanley Cup playoff series with the star-studded Pittsburgh Penguins, hoping to make even more history.

    April 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Penguins 0419 Blue Jackets outlast Pens in double-OT

    Matt Calvert banged home a rebound 1:10 into the second overtime and the Columbus Blue Jackets earned the first playoff victory in franchise history with a 4-3 win over the Pittsburgh Penguins on Saturday night.
    Pittsburgh’s Marc-Andre Fleury stuffed the initial shot by Cam Atkinson but Calvert stood all alone at the left post and wristed a shot into the open net to even the Eastern Conference quarterfinals at one game each.

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • Pirates 0419 Brewers rally to clip Pirates

    Ryan Braun hit two homers, including a two-run shot with two outs in the ninth inning that sent the Milwaukee Brewers over the Pittsburgh Pirates 8-7 Saturday night.
    Braun has five home runs this season after being suspended for the last 65 games of 2013 following Major League Baseball’s investigation into the Biogenesis drug scandal.

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • Area runners gearing for Boston Marathon

    The time was 12:15 p.m. It was Monday April 19, 1897.  Tom Burke had drawn a line across the dirt road with his foot. Eighteen men gathered near Metcalf’s Mill in Ashland, Massachusetts.

    April 19, 2014

  • SRU vs UPJ baseball0418 1 UPJ takes one, drops second

    John Fees’ spring baseball season accurately mirrors that of his Pitt-Johnstown team.
    Fees started slow, losing his first four decisions, but has rebounded nicely in the Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference West Division.

    April 18, 2014 2 Photos

  • Pirates 0418 Brewers ward off late Pirates rally bid

    Kyle Lohse pitched effectively into the seventh inning, Carlos Gomez homered and the Milwaukee Brewers beat the Pittsburgh Pirates 5-3 Friday night.
    Lohse (3-1) improved to 11-2 in his career against the Pirates, allowing one earned run in a win against them for the second time in six days.

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Drama lacking sans Tiger

    If professional golf saw its future at Augusta National last weekend, the sight had to be worse than choking on a 5-foot putt.
    The course was there in all its splendor.

    April 18, 2014

  • Penguins 0418 Penguins are wary of spunky Blue Jackets

    Sidney Crosby is used to the attention. It comes with the territory when you’re the best hockey player in the world.
    Still, the Pittsburgh Penguins star knows the spotlight becomes more acute in the Stanley Cup playoffs.

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo