The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA

State News

March 6, 2013

Prisoner appeals keep records office busy

HARRISBURG — Charles Hoyer, a convicted child molester serving time in state prison, filed an open records request in 2011 with a Lebanon County school district seeking a tax document related to a county detective.

School officials rejected his request, arguing that the document didn’t exist because the district had eliminated the occupational tax, and if the document did exist, it would have the home address of the detective on the paperwork.

Dissatisfied with the response from the school district, Hoyer filed an appeal with the Office of Open Records. The open records office determined that the district would have to release the document if the district  had it, though under Pennsylvania law, home addresses of law enforcement officers are redacted when they are released to the public.

It was one of 22 appeals Hoyer filed to the Office of Open Records in 2011.

In 2012, he was even busier, filing 39 appeals to the open records office.

Hoyer is not alone.

Prisoners account for 31 percent of the appeals filed to the Office of Open Records, executive director Terry Mutchler said Wednesday. In Pennsylvania, almost all government documents are considered open to the public, but there are 30 exceptions, most of them focused on information that is personal or relates to matters of public security.

Government offices, if they reject a request for a document, must explain which exception they believe is involved. The citizen then has the right to ask the Office of Open Records to determine if the government office is complying with the law.

Last year, the office dealt with 2,188 appeals, a 25 percent increase over 2011.

In response to complaints from the Office of Open Records and other state agencies, Senate Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, R-Chester, will introduce legislation later this month  to revise the records law in a number of ways, including placing new limits on what kind of documents are available to prison inmates.

Other possible changes involve setting up a fee structure for those who are seeking public documents for commercial use, and a variety of clarifications about whether quasi-governmental agencies are public or not. Records of volunteer fire departments, for instance, would mostly be considered private. Campus police would be considered the same as any other police department and expected to comply with the open records law.

 Erik Arneson, communications and policy director for Pileggi’s office, said that the legislation would change the rules so that inmates may only request documents containing personal information about them.

The idea does not sit well with advocates for prisoners.

William DiMascio, executive director of the Pennsylvania Prison Society, based in Philadelphia, said it is inappropriate to diminish the rights of inmates because government officials do not feel like they have the resources to handle the demands being placed on the office.

Pileggi’s language mirrors the approach taken in Wisconsin, where inmates are only allowed to file record requests related to documents about themselves or relatives.

Other states, including Virginia, have entirely excluded prisoners from access to open records.

The Pennsylvania Open Records Office has 11 employees – including seven attorneys who hear appeals. The office is asking the state to provide the additional funding needed to add two attorneys and support staff, Mutchler said.

Gov. Tom Corbett’s proposed budget would increase funding for the Open Records Office by about $37,000. But the $1.4 million proposed for the office is $400,000 short of what it needs, Mutchler said.

“The caseloads our attorneys are handling are about 400 cases, and that is more than assistant district attorneys in many counties,” Mutchler said.

In addition to the appeals, the office is also involved in about 200 court cases, in which either the government agency or the person who requested the document, appealed the open records office ruling.

Pileggi’s legislation would not completely eliminate the prisoner appeals. Open records office databases show that inmates regularly seek records about themselves, and file appeals when the Department of Corrections and other agencies decline to provide the information.

There were 63 appeals filed in 2012 involving disputes in which inmates wanted the prison system to provide documents that the Department of Corrections insisted it did not have. In many cases, the prisoners were seeking legal documents, such as sentencing orders.

“In some cases, they just want the documents so they can have paper they turn over and use to write,” Mutchler said. In the case of sentencing orders, inmates may want to know the exact number of days they are supposed to be incarcerated so that they can keep track to make sure they don’t spend more time than necessary behind bars, she said.

Click here to subscribe to The Tribune-Democrat print edition.

Click here to subscribe to The Tribune-Democrat e-edition.

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
State News
  • 4-year-old killed by van after dad’s funeral, police say

    Police in southeastern Pennsylvania say a 4-year-old boy was struck and killed by a passing van hours after returning from his father’s funeral.

    April 14, 2014

  • Woman gets 6 to 12 years in infant kidnapping

    A Pittsburgh area woman was sentenced to six to 12 years in prison after she was convicted of kidnapping an infant by luring the mother to a Fayette County motel with a phony story about a commercial photo shoot for disposable diapers.

    April 11, 2014

  • APTOPIX High School Stabbings.jpg Lawyer: Evaluate stabbing suspect’s mental health

    The attorney for a 16-year-old accused of stabbing 21 other students and a security guard at their high school said Thursday he wants to have a mental health expert evaluate the boy and hopes to have the case moved to juvenile court.

    April 10, 2014 1 Photo

  • Obamas send prayers to school stabbing victims

    President Barack Obama and first lady Michelle Obama are sending their thoughts and prayers to the victims of a stabbing spree at a Pennsylvania high school.

    April 9, 2014

  • High School Stabbings.jpg Stabbing spree at Westmoreland County high school leaves 20 injured

    A 16-year-old armed with two knives went on a stabbing and slashing spree at a high school near Pittsburgh on Wednesday, leaving 20 people injured, including a school police officer who eventually subdued him with the help of an assistant principal, authorities said.

    April 9, 2014 1 Photo

  • APTOPIX stabbings.jpg Student flashed 2 knives, injured 20 in Westmoreland County school, police say

    A 16-year-old boy "was flashing two knives around" when he injured 19 students and a school police officer who eventually subdued him with the help of an assistant principal at a high school near Pittsburgh on Wednesday, a police chief said.

    April 9, 2014 1 Photo

  • Police: Man killed by train was texting

    Police say a man killed by a commuter train in suburban Philadelphia was texting a friend when he was struck while walking on the tracks.

    April 8, 2014

  • Daniel.jpg Investigators seek cause of fire that killed three brothers

    Authorities searched the rubble of a burned-out farm house over the weekend for the cause of a fire that took the lives of three young brothers left home alone while their widowed mother worked the overnight shift at a direct mail company.

    April 7, 2014 2 Photos

  • Wozniak, John Lawmakers want more aid for cities

    Several bills circulating at the Capitol would open improvement zones more quickly or allow smaller cities to participate.
    Sen. John Wozniak, D-Westmont, wants to make the concept available to more cities the size of Johnstown.

    April 3, 2014 1 Photo

  • barbour021614.jpg No shows escaped death by Craigslist killer

    The young woman who says she was driven by satanic spirts to commit a cross-country murder spree over the last six years says authorities are not taking her claims seriously and that she tried to lure other central Pennslyvania men into her death snare with online companionship ads but they didn't show up.

    April 3, 2014 1 Photo 2 Stories

Poll

Do you think that Jack Williams will get the 270 signatures from city residents needed in order to have a referendum placed on a municipal ballot to have the city's pressure test mandate repealed?

Yes
No
I'm not sure
     View Results
Order Photos


Photo Slideshow

House Ads