The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA

Zachary Hubbard

September 8, 2012

Zachary Hubbard | End political deadlock and enact an energy policy

— My wife and I enjoyed a long journey over the Labor Day weekend.

Our drive took us southward along the Appalachian Ridge to the beautiful mountains of southeastern Kentucky where I was born. It was a wonderful trip.

However, one aspect of the drive was not so great – gasoline in Kentucky costs nearly $4 per gallon. Each time I filled my tank, I couldn’t help but wonder how the local people survive in this economy.

Poverty abounds here in western Pennsylvania, but it pales in comparison to southeastern Kentucky.

Both regions are coal producers, but there’s a significant difference between them.

Western Pennsylvania has a diverse economy driven not only by coal, but also by manufacturing, a technology boom in the Greater Pittsburgh region and the Marcellus Shale. Southeastern Kentucky has a coal-based economy and little else.

Kentuckians feel the sting of President Obama’s self-styled “war on coal” that is being waged through environmental regulations such as Utility Maximum Achievable Control Technology (MACT).

Utility MACT regulations make the building of new, coal-fired electric generating stations cost-prohibitive and require existing stations to spend millions to remain operational.

This drives the already punishing cost of electricity even higher.

Driving through Kentucky’s mountains, one sees many businesses with signs boasting “Friends of Coal” and vehicle bumper stickers reminding us, “Coal miners keep the lights on.”

Federal pressure on the mining industry has become so severe that the United Mine Workers of America union, traditionally a hardcore supporter of Democrats, has declined to endorse President Obama’s re-election.

It has also refrained from endorsing Mitt Romney.

As I’ve stated before, energy is key to America’s economic recovery. Coal is but a single component of the nation’s energy resources. High oil and natural gas prices increase the cost of electricity generation, which increases the operating expense for manufacturing and other industries. Rising gasoline and diesel prices trickle down through the economy, increasing the shipping cost for food, manufactured goods and other products. In each case, the end result is a higher cost of living for American consumers.

Energy prices directly or indirectly affect the price of nearly everything in the economy. If our political leaders could succeed in controlling rising electricity rates and reducing the cost of fuel by even $1 per gallon, it would create a flood of disposable consumer income to help bolster our sagging economy.

Unfortunately, for decades, Democrats and Republicans alike have failed to develop a viable national energy policy.

An effective policy must capitalize on America’s vast natural energy resources and reduce its dependency on foreign oil.

The Republican “drill baby drill” approach has proven troublesome for multiple reasons. These include the BP oil rig disaster in the Gulf of Mexico, environmental concerns surrounding the questionable practice of hydraulic fracking used in natural gas drilling, and pollution produced by coal mining and coal- and oil-burning electric generating stations.

The Democrat approach to an energy policy has suffered from scandals such as the Solyndra solar-panel manufacturing fiasco, questionable subsidies paid to a fledgling wind-energy industry whose technology is still years from being cost-efficient, draconian regulation of the energy sector, and the shunning of energy production through coal and nuclear power.

The politicians aren’t totally to blame, however. Solving America’s energy woes is a wicked problem. The Financial Times lexicon defines a wicked problem as “… a complex problem for which there is no simple method of solution. Wicked problems are ones for which there is no clear stopping rule – you cannot say for sure that you are done with the problem.

“Working on it more might well bring forth a better solution. There is no single right answer and every attempt can matter because it affects the things people depend upon.”

Wicked problems don’t lend themselves to one-party political solutions and cannot be easily addressed in an ever-changing political system with an overlapping, 2-4-6-year federal election cycle. Finding a solution to America’s energy crisis requires a new approach, which must include bipartisan participation, compromise and solutions developed by patriots, not politicians.

California has demonstrated that such solutions are possible. In years past, its legislature was responsible for establishing legislative districts inside the state. The majority party at the time always held the greatest sway in redistricting decisions. This resulted in gerrymandered political boundaries drawn to favor the majority party in future elections.

This changed in 2008, when California established a Citizens Redistricting Commission. California’s congressional and state legislative lines are now drawn by a 14-member, independent commission created through a ballot initiative.

According to professor Justin Levitt of the Loyola University Law School, “Commissioners must have voted in at least two of the last three statewide elections, and may not have changed party affiliation for at least five years.

“Neither commissioners nor immediate family may have been, within 10 years of appointment, a candidate for federal or state office or member of a party central committee; an officer, employee, or paid consultant to a federal or state candidate or party; a registered lobbyist or paid legislative staff; or a donor of more than $2,000 to an elected candidate. Furthermore, neither commissioners nor immediate family may be staff, consultants, or contractors for state or federal government while serving on the commission.”

Solving our nation’s energy crisis requires a similar approach. An apolitical commission that combines sound science, practical economics and good old American horse sense could finally end the political deadlock hindering the development of a viable national energy policy.

Try to imagine what energy independence would mean for our country. Each time you see a wounded warrior who lost a limb in the Middle East, and each time the media report another American service member has been killed there, ask yourself: “Would he or she have been placed in harm’s way if our country was energy independent?”

If your answer is “no,” then tell your elected officials you want real change.

Zachary Hubbard is a retired Army officer and freelance writer residing in the Greater Pittsburgh area.

Click here to subscribe to The Tribune-Democrat print edition.

Click here to subscribe to The Tribune-Democrat e-edition.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Zachary Hubbard
  • Zachary Hubbard NEW Zachary Hubbard | Some actions defy explanation

    Like a poorly delivered joke that leaves a comedian’s audience waiting for the punch line, there are scores of factors about American society that make me moan, “I don’t get it.” Sometimes it seems as if we Americans are losing our minds. I see evidence of this every day.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Zachary Hubbard NEW Zachary Hubbard | Obama should study Powell Doctrine

    During his tenure as the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Gen. Colin Powell elaborated on eight questions he believed should be considered before committing U.S. military forces to war.

    June 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • Zachary Hubbard NEW Zachary Hubbard | EPA taking jobs, hope from coal country

    I just returned from a visit to my birthplace in Harlan County, Kentucky, which lies in the southeast corner of the state.

    May 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Zachary Hubbard NEW Zachary Hubbard | Random thoughts on politics, our money

    Lately, the news has contained more baloney than usual. Let’s start with Ukraine, where I left off last time.

    April 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • Zachary Hubbard NEW Zachary Hubbard | Obama's diplomacy pickle: Crimea crisis

    With all of the political pundits piling on about the current crisis in the Ukraine, I’m puzzled that I have yet to hear anyone seriously discuss Russia’s Near Abroad policy.

    March 10, 2014 1 Photo

  • Zachary Hubbard | Federal contracting system broken, out of control

    I’ve been feeling surly. It started several weeks ago when Congress passed legislation making large cuts in the annual cost-of-living pay adjustments for active and retired military personnel.

    February 24, 2014

  • Zachary Hubbard NEW Zachary Hubbard | It was so cold ...

    Late last night I got a phone call from a friend stationed at Minot Air Force Base in North Dakota. He told me that since early morning, the snow had been coming down steadily.

    January 13, 2014 1 Photo

  • Zachary Hubbard NEW Zachary Hubbard | Throwing veterans under the bus

    Americans love honoring their military veterans. They cheer loudly for troops returning home from combat zones in far away countries; they hold veterans’ parades and decorate veterans’ graves; and they walk up to veterans and thank them for their service. Unfortunately, most of the honors end there.

    December 18, 2013 1 Photo

  • Zachary Hubbard NEW Zachary Hubbard | Republican Party is in need of a facelift

    Thirty-nine House Democrats facing re-election in 2014 recently jumped ship and sided with Republicans to vote for changes in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, better known as Obamacare.

    November 25, 2013 1 Photo

  • Zachary Hubbard NEW Zachary Hubbard | For military brats, Germany was a magical place

    A long chapter in U.S. history is closing. The once behemoth U.S. military forces in Germany are slowly withdrawing. In April, the last Army tanks were shipped home, marking the first time in almost
    70 years there were no American tanks on German soil. While most Americans would consider this a political development, for some of us, it’s quite personal.

    November 5, 2013 1 Photo


What is the biggest key to reducing gun violence in Johnstown?

Tackling the area's drug problem.
Controlling folks moving into city housing.
Monitoring folks in treatment centers and halfway houses.
Tougher sentencing by the court system.
More police on the streets.

     View Results
Order Photos

Photo Slideshow

House Ads